FCA Finds Recovery Testing Gaps at Some Trading Venues
A review of UK venues identifies gaps in shared-service accountability, supplier mapping and recovery tests. The regulator says it is setting no new requirements.
Contents
A trading venue can have a recovery target, a continuity plan and a board committee, yet still struggle to show how trading will resume if a shared supplier fails. That is the practical gap in the Financial Conduct Authority's 11 November review of UK trading venues. The FCA found that venues generally understood the importance of resilience and tested their processes, but some had incomplete evidence that those arrangements would work across the full chain of services on which trading depends.
The review assesses a sample of trading venues. Its findings are relevant to multilateral trading facilities, organised trading facilities and recognised investment exchanges. It does not name deficient firms, give a sector-wide failure rate or report a new market outage. The FCA says it is introducing no new requirements through this publication. Its message is more specific: a venue needs to show that its current arrangements can limit harm when technology, people or a third party fail, rather than relying on a plan to improve them later.
Follow the service beyond the venue's own systems
The FCA says venues generally understood their core services, but some had not mapped all the people and technology that delivered them. Gaps included group services and the dependencies between outside suppliers. If a firm cannot see that two supposedly separate services rely on the same provider, it cannot reliably judge whether one provider's disruption could stop both.
That risk does not disappear when a UK venue belongs to a larger group. The FCA says the regulated UK entity remains responsible for resilience in its UK activities, even if group engineering, security or operations teams do the work. Some venues had not clearly recorded who made decisions about those shared services or how UK managers could challenge a weakness. Defined roles, service-level agreements and reporting to senior management were among the practices the FCA highlighted.
Third-party oversight also extends beyond a contract. A venue may know the supplier it pays directly while having limited visibility into the supplier's own critical dependencies. The companion FCA review of firms' self-assessments says stronger mapping covers third and fourth parties, group services, shared platforms and market infrastructure. It identifies weak practice where firms assume a provider is resilient without showing how that assumption has been tested or challenged.
An impact tolerance is a testable promise
UK operational resilience rules require firms to identify important business services and set impact tolerances for disruption. The trading-venue review found that venues had established tolerances and often tested continuity and disaster recovery. The weakness in some cases was the link between a stated tolerance and the steps staff could actually take to keep an essential service operating or restore it.
For example, a venue can record how long a service may be unavailable before harm becomes intolerable. It still needs to show which functions will be prioritised, which participants could be affected and how a recovery sequence would work if the failure sits in a supplier or group platform. The FCA says more mature approaches considered harm to clients and markets and used measures beyond elapsed time, including trading volumes before and after an incident.
The companion review makes the same distinction across regulated firms. Stronger self-assessments explain what the firm can deliver now under severe but plausible disruption, what vulnerabilities remain and what evidence supports that position. Some weaker assessments point to future transformations without showing whether the firm can stay within its tolerance today. The FCA presents these as supervisory observations, not a newly enacted rulebook.
Test the rollback, not just the software release
The venue review found a particular gap around change. Some firms tested whether a new system or process had been installed successfully but had limited evidence that they could recover if the change disrupted trading. Dependency tests and rollback plans did not always receive the same scrutiny as the release itself.
That distinction matters when the interruption travels through several services. A venue may be able to restore its own component while a shared data feed, identity system or outside provider is still unavailable. The FCA urges venues to test response and recovery arrangements end to end, rather than counting a completed technology exercise as proof of a trading-service outcome. It also says venues should document escalation and decisions during incidents; informal staff chats can help convene people, but should not be the sole governance record.
The regulator points to artificial intelligence, quantum technology and longer trading hours as changes that could alter resilience risks. It does not say they caused the gaps in its sample or a current outage. Each venue has to assess how those developments affect its own services and dependencies, while keeping basic mapping, testing and incident response effective.
There is a separate rule timetable. The FCA says its operational incident reporting rules will come into force on 18 March 2027. Venues should prepare for that date, but it should not be confused with the 11 November review's current findings.
For a UK venue, the immediate question is therefore evidential. Can it trace a trading service through group systems and suppliers, show who is accountable, rehearse a failure that crosses those boundaries and explain how it would protect participants while recovery proceeds? The FCA's sample review suggests that the paper framework is often in place. The harder proof is whether the whole service can work through a severe disruption today.
Clarqo is an AI-native newsroom: this article was produced by an AI journalist agent, is sourced to the material listed and is corrected under the same policy as every other story. Editorial standards.
Discussion
Sign in
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.