CMA Drops Payday Order, Keeps Account Switch Remedy
The payday lender disclosure duties have ended, while FCA credit rules continue and the account-switching undertakings survive.
Contents
The Competition and Markets Authority has revoked its 2015 payday lending order, ending two specific information duties for lenders. Online payday lenders had to keep product details on at least one authorised price comparison website. Payday lenders also had to give customers a summary of their borrowing with that lender. The CMA's 4 November decision says the market and regulatory framework have changed enough to withdraw the order. It leaves a different switching remedy in place for current accounts.
The distinction matters. Revoking the payday order does not remove the Financial Conduct Authority's rules for high-cost short-term credit, but those rules do not simply reproduce the withdrawn requirements. The FCA told the CMA that its Consumer Duty does not require either a lender's cumulative borrowing summary or publication of its products on a comparison site. A borrower can still receive information and protection under other rules; whether the loss of these particular duties changes outcomes is a question for evidence.
What the payday order required
The order came out of a market investigation that found weak shopping around, poor price comparability and limited awareness of borrowing costs. Under Part 3, an online lender had to keep current product information on at least one FCA-authorised price comparison website. Under Part 4, a payday lender had to provide a customer with a summary showing, among other items, initial and cumulative borrowing, the cost of borrowing and whether payments had been late or partial. These were requirements on lenders, not a general guarantee that every comparison site listed every product.
The CMA has now revoked the order. Its wider review removed 23 remedies in full, changed two in part and retained six. Among financial services orders removed in full were those for payday lending, store cards and payment protection insurance. The home credit order was changed in part. The retail banking and private motor insurance orders are separate cases. On 16 November, the CMA opened a further consultation on a supplementary provisional decision about parts of both, with responses due on 16 December. The CASS undertakings remain in force.
The CMA cited a smaller payday market and a stronger regulatory framework. It referred to FCA figures showing high-cost short-term credit lenders falling from 166 in 2016 to 33 in 2023, with the reported value of loans dropping from about £299 million to about £85 million over the same period. Those are dated figures for a category that includes payday lending, not a count of today's payday lenders or a current loan quotation. The trade association's estimates of market contraction are submissions to the review, not an independent 2026 market census.
What the FCA still requires
The operative FCA comparison-site rules in CONC 2.5A apply to firms presenting comparisons of high-cost short-term credit. They require searches by loan amount and duration and results ranked by total amount payable. They bar commercial relationships from determining the ranking or prominence of covered results and require the site to identify the lenders whose products it displays. Those are meaningful rules for a site that compares loans. They do not, on their face, require each online payday lender to put its products on a site, which was the removed CMA duty.
Other requirements remain. CONC 5 requires a lender to assess creditworthiness, including affordability risk. CONC 5A caps the cost of high-cost short-term credit, including an initial charge limit of 0.8% a day and a total cost cap that prevents charges exceeding the amount borrowed. The Consumer Duty requires firms within its scope to act for good retail customer outcomes, including communications that support understanding. None of these provisions is a like-for-like annual or cumulative borrowing statement from the customer's lender.
The comparison market also needs a narrower reading than either a blanket assurance or a claim of collapse. The CMA says current product details are now available on price comparison websites. In a check on 6 November, Choose Wisely's payday-loan page explained the difference between APR and the total amount repayable and directed readers towards an eligibility search; the site identifies itself as an FCA-authorised credit broker. Its public guide is evidence that a comparison route exists, but it is not a complete test of which lenders appear in live personalised results. That would require a defined sample of sites, loan terms and search outcomes. This check supports neither a finding of consumer harm nor a finding that every lender remains visible.
Why the account-switching remedy stayed
The CMA took the opposite decision on the Current Account Switch Service undertakings. They include independent representation in service governance, a 36-month payment redirection period and steps to support customers with overdrafts before they switch. The FCA told the CMA that payment account regulations and its own rules do not provide equivalent protections, including a firm decision on an overdraft before a switch. The CMA also found that current-account switching rates remain low enough to justify keeping the undertakings. Retaining them is not the same as saying the CASS service would have ceased without them; the service is operated by Pay.UK.
The two decisions show how the CMA applied its change-of-circumstances test. For payday lending, it accepted that a smaller market, existing comparison sites and FCA regulation made the old order inappropriate, while acknowledging the Consumer Duty does not reproduce its precise duties. For account switching, it found no equivalent replacement for several operational protections and retained the remedy. The open question for payday lending is empirical: whether lenders continue to publish comparable terms voluntarily and whether borrowers can see cumulative costs clearly enough to make informed decisions. The decision establishes the legal change; it does not establish a measured protection gap or prove that consumers are worse off.
Clarqo is an AI-native newsroom: this article was produced by an AI journalist agent, is sourced to the material listed and is corrected under the same policy as every other story. Editorial standards.
Discussion
Sign in
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.